← Back to rate browser
Net worth & break-even comparison
Compares two loan structures the way a finance desk would: it holds your income the same both ways,
has both spend the same monthly budget, invests whatever the cheaper-payment loan frees up at your
return, and compares total net worth over time. The number that actually decides it is the
break-even return — the market return at which the two tie, i.e. the internal rate of return of
choosing the shorter loan. Beat it and the longer loan (invest the difference) wins; miss it and the shorter
loan wins. This sidesteps the trap that discounting the debt alone at one rate always flatters the
shorter, lower-rate loan.
Looking to rank the real scraped loans from 400+ credit unions instead? →
Compare by true cost (NPV)
Assumptions
Net worth over time (same budget, invest the difference)
Loan A
Loan B
sell year
Decision curve — advantage of A over B vs. your investment return
Where this line crosses zero is the break-even return (= the IRR of picking the shorter loan).
Left of it (lower returns) the shorter loan wins; right of it, the longer loan + investing wins.
Year-by-year ledger
Every modeled cash flow, both scenarios — payment, interest, tax refund, amount invested,
side account, home equity, net worth — so the model is fully auditable.
Model & caveats.
- Same budget: each month both scenarios spend the larger of the two required payments;
the loan with the smaller payment invests the remainder at your after-tax return. When a loan is paid off,
its whole budget flows to investing. Points are paid at closing from that budget, so the loan that skips
points invests them instead.
- Net worth = home equity (price × appreciation − loan balance) + side investment account.
The house value is common to both, so it cancels in the difference — the winner never depends
on the appreciation guess, only the level does.
- Tax: deductible interest (capped at the $750K acquisition-debt portion) plus year-one purchase
points, credited at your marginal rate above the standard-deduction floor (MFJ $32,200 − $10K other
itemized), as a yearly refund into the side account. Set marginal to 0 to turn off.
- Break-even return is found by re-running the whole simulation across returns 0–15% and finding
where A and B tie at your sell year — the honest IRR-style answer a single-discount-rate NPV can't give.
- Ignores PMI, differing closing costs, and selling costs (same house → cancels). Nominal dollars unless
“today's $” is checked (deflates both by inflation — changes levels, not the winner). Advertised
rates assume top-tier credit; this is an information tool, not advice.