← Back to rate browser

Net worth & break-even comparison

Compares two loan structures the way a finance desk would: it holds your income the same both ways, has both spend the same monthly budget, invests whatever the cheaper-payment loan frees up at your return, and compares total net worth over time. The number that actually decides it is the break-even return — the market return at which the two tie, i.e. the internal rate of return of choosing the shorter loan. Beat it and the longer loan (invest the difference) wins; miss it and the shorter loan wins. This sidesteps the trap that discounting the debt alone at one rate always flatters the shorter, lower-rate loan.

Assumptions

your opportunity cost
0 = ignore deduction

Net worth over time (same budget, invest the difference)

Loan A Loan B sell year

Decision curve — advantage of A over B vs. your investment return

Where this line crosses zero is the break-even return (= the IRR of picking the shorter loan). Left of it (lower returns) the shorter loan wins; right of it, the longer loan + investing wins.

Year-by-year ledger

Every modeled cash flow, both scenarios — payment, interest, tax refund, amount invested, side account, home equity, net worth — so the model is fully auditable.

Model & caveats.